Revenge? (OOC)

Aug 8, 2025 7:02 pm
Out of character chatter about Revenge? can go here to avoid cluttering up the Roleplay thread.
OOC:
Use the OOC tag in your posts in the Roleplay thread, as needed, to clarify what is happening or suggest Moves.
This is for longer questions and answers related to that Roleplay. Basically: if it needs a back-and-forth, put it here.
General rules questions not answered in the Help! or Resources threads can go in General Chat or here if they are directly related to the RP.

Add a link back to the post in question so we can have context. After posting you can right-click on the orange header and select 'copy link address' (or whatever your browser calls it), then paste that in your OOC post.
Aug 8, 2025 7:47 pm
The way I which Persephone and Emma have been kind of trading off being traumatized and having lighter scenes has been interesting, to say the least! Such a contrast, first in one direction and now the other. Which is all to say I am impressed with your description of Emma's trauma, @Delirium. I really feel for her and recognize that numbness, for sure.

meanwhile, Benji is actually doing something to figure stuff out! I'm glad someone is.
Aug 8, 2025 8:07 pm
Drgwen says:
... I am impressed with your description of Emma's trauma, ...
Agreed. It is almost disturbingly evocative.

@Delirium are you alright with how this is going? I know it is hard on Emma (though we know fixing the scars is well within our capabilities... for a 'price').

Let us know how long you want to wallow in your hollowness, I brought ... Waterman into the scene to move it along, but don't want to rush you or Emma, also let me know if you have any desires for how the scene goes from here.
Aug 8, 2025 8:21 pm
Drgwen says:
... I am impressed with your description of Emma's trauma, ...
vagueGM says:
Agreed. It is almost disturbingly evocative.
Thanks. It has been an interesting writing experience, and I enjoyed it, in a strange sort of way.

As for Emma; I think she will definitely want to get herself properly fixed. After that though....I really don't know. She would probably want to take a long break from it all, maybe disengage from the entire supernatural world altogether. But we will see how it goes.
Aug 8, 2025 8:22 pm
Delirium says:
... maybe disengage from the entire supernatural world altogether. ...
Ha! Good luck with that.
Aug 8, 2025 8:34 pm
vagueGM says:
You can roll to Put a Face to a Name with Wild if you think you know of him.
I rolled to see if Emma knows him (added to my last post), and it's a '10', even with a -1 to wild...
I don't think it would make sense for him to owe Emma a favor. Lets go instead with 'learn something interesting and useful about them', besides the normal effect of a hit. Also, I finally get to advance! Yay!!!
Aug 8, 2025 8:43 pm
Delirium says:
... Also, I finally get to advance! Yay!!!
Yay!

Any idea what you will be taking? No hurry.
Aug 8, 2025 8:57 pm
Can I pick 'Potent' from the specter playbook as a 'move from another playbook'?
I'm not sure it is really considered 'a move'...
Aug 8, 2025 9:06 pm
Delirium says:
Can I pick 'Potent' from the specter playbook as a 'move from another playbook'?
I'm not sure it is really considered 'a move'...
Let's take a look...

Yes, it is definitely 'a Move', so you are welcome to take it if you want.

Personally I generally find pure Stat boosts boring, but this one does help with your frequent rolling of Let It Out, so it is, by no means, a bad option for you.

Can you describe how you, somehow become more 'Potent' though recent experience? (Or grow into it, even if you don't feel potent right now.:). Not necessary, but it is fun to let the Move names inform the character so they are not just Stat boosts. :)

We can talk about any other Advancement thoughts you have as well, if you want.
Aug 8, 2025 9:10 pm
I kinda like Emma's 'let it out' abilities, and being better at them would be nice, certainly more appealing than a new ability from another playbook. I am growing into liking the 'Witch' playbook more and more, and I can see Emma wanting to learn some magic to protect herself after her latest ordeal. So for now, I'd like to at least put into the narrative that she has the potential to do magic. If she commits to it or not I really can't tell right now.
Aug 8, 2025 9:21 pm
Delirium says:
... I am growing into liking the 'Witch' playbook more and more, and I can see Emma wanting to learn some magic to protect herself after her latest ordeal. ...
I only glanced at the playbook when it came out, but you we could also look at taking a magic Move now and getting your Spirit up later (possibly via Corruption Advance?). If it were just for 'Witch Magic' I would say taking a Stat boost to power that is a subpar option (we never know how long it might take to get another Advance), but since you are already, maybe, leaning towards 'slightly magic' we can start to flavour your Let It Out as having a magic element and make it more Potent now.

You can also grab a Let It Out Ability from another playbook (via your If You Can't Beat 'Em Corruption Move) giving you more options with that.

Speaking of... Do you think you have 'ignored your mortal commitments or relationships to deal with the supernatural', leaving David bedridden and alone? If so, that is your Corruption Trigger, so Mark Corruption. :)
Aug 8, 2025 9:46 pm
Delirium says:
... I am growing into liking the 'Witch' playbook more and more, and I can see Emma wanting to learn some magic to protect herself ...
I am not sure what parts of that Playbook you are looking at, the only Move that see that would really benefit you is Fur Black as Black for a familiar to allow you to use Heart for Let It Out. The Benign and Dangerous Magics are not Moves they are Features like your Relationships.

If you want to learn those Magics you will need to find a coven to teach you, this can be done by Changing to a new Playbook when you Advance (we can talk about waiving the 'after five advances' since PbP is slow), but can also be done in the fiction by finding and befriending a coven and convincing them to trust you enough to teach you... (doing it in the fiction would not (necessarily) change you from the Aware Playbook, though that could be a price they ask of you, we would need to see how it goes).
Aug 8, 2025 10:28 pm
I need to start finding ways/reasons to roll Circle! I also wanna start causing more Corruption -- I keep forgetting. One issue with the style of playing I often fall into is simply following the narrative, exploring the character, etc, rather than thinking explicitly about how to invoke mechanics.
Aug 8, 2025 10:34 pm
Also, I am curious what other people think about something. I am considering bringing Circe in on Persephone's secret..

My question is, that would definitely change the narrative tension with Circe, AND it would mean that Persephone has some familial support, which I think would change the tenor of her story. Do folks think that would be an improvement? A mistake? Or just an option to explore?
Aug 9, 2025 4:23 am
Drgwen says:
... I often fall into is simply following the narrative, exploring the character, etc, rather than thinking explicitly about how to invoke mechanics. ...
Urban Shadow is particularly hard on that style.

I have been toying with running a Monster of the Week game without Hit Points and Experience: If you get hurt you deal with the narrative consequences of your injury in the ways that that Condition would affect you in the fiction; if you want to gain a new Feature or Move, or improve a Stat, you come up with a plan as to how you would do that in the fiction. You don't have a Playbook, as such, you start with a reasonable assortment of Features from the various playbooks (possible the more mundane ones?) and add on as you play.

This, obviously, requires trust in the players, and the GM, so we don't end up with power-loading all the 'best' features from all the playbooks.
[ +- ] origin
Aug 9, 2025 4:34 am
vagueGM says:
but you we could also look at taking a magic Move now and getting your Spirit up later
I don’t want to make that much of a commitment. There is something fun about playing a mortal who is out of her depth, surviving (..and I hope more than that 😊 ) only by her wits and charm. Gaining real supernatural power might allow her to use actual charm to deal with her problems, but I feel somehow that it would make things a bit less exciting.

I don’t know.

I keep going back and forth on this in my mind, which is why I would rather not to make that choice right now until I am sure I am ready for it. What I know for certain is that I want Emma to have ‘the gift’, which we can spin into more interesting stories and interactions. Taking a ‘Let it out’ ability using ‘If You Can't Beat 'Em’ would probably be the next step, rather than changing the whole playbook, once I finally make up my mind about it.

For now ‘Potent’ does sound like the most fun to me, mainly because I want Emma to be a good investigator. Sneaking/breaking into places she’s not supposed to be, finding clues. I enjoy playing her like that, even if it inevitably leads her from one disaster straight into the next.
vagueGM says:
Do you think you have 'ignored your mortal commitments or relationships to deal with the supernatural
Not sure about that one. Emma was sure she could be back before David ever noticed. It wasn’t a conscious choice to abandon him so much as a failure to keep all the balls in the air. It is different, than, say, her decision to skip dinner with her in-laws so she could attend the party in Arundel. THAT was a deliberate choice of her, and she should have gotten corruption for that, even if she did make it up for them later.
There have been a couple of other moments like that, I think, but this one feels less clear-cut. Not that I mind the corruption (I have a few other corruption advances I’ve been eyeing ), but it doesn’t quite feel like it had the same element of personal choice.
Aug 9, 2025 6:47 am
drgwen says:
My question is, that would definitely change the narrative tension with Circe
It might change the tension, but not necessarily in a positive way, especially if she tells Circe everything. Her sister might not be as understanding as she hopes if she knows Pers job is basically convincing people to sell their souls to the devil. Most people, I would assume, wouldn't.
Aug 9, 2025 6:55 am
Drgwen says:
My question is, that would definitely change the narrative tension with Circe, AND it would mean that Persephone has some familial support, which I think would change the tenor of her story. Do folks think that would be an improvement? A mistake? Or just an option to explore?
Personally, I would definitely be interested in seeing how it plays out if you decide to take your story in that direction! :D
Last edited August 9, 2025 6:56 am
Aug 9, 2025 2:11 pm
Delirium says:
... There is something fun about playing a mortal who is out of her depth ... Gaining real supernatural power might ... make things a bit less exciting. ...
So true.
Delirium says:
... rather than changing the whole playbook ...
We can always change the Playbook later, when the time is right. That can be a big rejigger of the character, so planning it out now is often counter-productive. As you say: just keep playing it as you have and see how it goes.
Delirium says:
... ‘Potent’ ... from one disaster straight into the next. ...
Sounds about right. :)
Delirium says:
... Emma was sure she could be back before David ever noticed. It wasn’t a conscious choice to abandon him so much as a failure to keep all the balls in the air. ...
Up to you.

Not being able to keep all the balls in the air is, I think, the point of this Trigger?
Delirium says:
... it doesn’t quite feel like it had the same element of personal choice. ...
You did, however, choose to wander into a nest of vampires, even after seeing the dead bodies, you figured getting to the safe was more important than keeping yourself safe for your loved ones... seems a bit like you are putting the supernatural before your Relationships...? It's not like you could not predict something like this could happen. :)

You also chose to let Tara feed on you, but maybe you thought it would be more like when Elliot did it, or when you had friends to back you with Chablis and you were 'in control'... you might know better next time, especially after the scar-scare.

But, as I say, it is up to you.
Aug 9, 2025 2:11 pm
Drgwen says:
... bringing Circe in on Persephone's secret... change the narrative tension with Circe ...
Circe certainly thinks she is up for it. Not including her could have repercussions, too.
Drgwen says:
... would mean that Persephone has some familial support ..
You think so? It could also lead to Persephone losing that familial support if things go badly. As Delirium says, maybe glossing over some of the more horrific specifics would be in order?
load next

You do not have permission to post in this thread.