1.2 - Cragmaw Cave
load previous
Feb 5, 2026 6:19 pm
Hearing the alarmingly loud—under the circumstances—rustle of what could only be his compatriots clomping through the woods like an entire herd of ankheg, Alex quickly retreats and catches Igrem and Nelly before they could alert the goblins. Quickly describing the layout, Alex whispers "So what should we do? Try to ambush? Try to bluff our way in? There are clearly at least half a dozen goblins in the cave. Probably more."
Feb 6, 2026 11:18 am
"Is it wise, and part of our mission, to confront these goblins head on? Now that we know where they dwell, maybe it is a better move to reach our destination fast and warn there of the danger. We can always come back later in bigger numbers." suggest Igrem, wary of being in hostile territory. He looks around in the trees, from time to time, anxiously.
Feb 6, 2026 3:21 pm
Nelly speaks to Igrem while Alex scouts ahead.
Our self-appointed mission is a rescue mission. We are not here to hunt goblins. If there is no one to save, then we return to the vagon and continue on the original missioin of excorting the wagon to Phandelver
Our self-appointed mission is a rescue mission. We are not here to hunt goblins. If there is no one to save, then we return to the vagon and continue on the original missioin of excorting the wagon to Phandelver
Feb 6, 2026 3:49 pm
Hard to know if there is no one to save without checking, to be frank, Alex whispers.
Feb 7, 2026 5:25 pm
"Alright then, it is up to you. But yet again, a rescue mission with more help and preparation might have higher chances of success..." concedes Igrem. He will of course follow his companions, whatever they decide.
Feb 9, 2026 5:47 am
Alex whispers to the others I am going to sneak up closer and see what those noises are. My guess is they are goblins. Perhaps we can get the jump on them. Alex pats himself down, ensuring that all items that can clink, clank, clop, or clod are tied down and muffled. Taking a deep breath, Alex begins to move forward as silently as he can [Hide: (1/round) You may either Move or Hide for free.]
OOC:
Alex hides and then will sneak up as close as he feels safe to I19 or I20 and reconnoiter the cave opening. From there, depending on how many foes there are, if any, he may try to sneak around them, given he is hidden now and is not intending to break cover.Last edited February 9, 2026 6:37 pm
Feb 9, 2026 4:31 pm
Nelly stays far enough back to still have an eye on Alex, but not hindering her scouting. She knows that she is loud and noisy, and that is not needed right now.
Feb 9, 2026 8:14 pm
Alex, as you circle slightly to the east side of the stream, keeping the sound of running water between you and the cave mouth, you notice something that doesn’t quite belong. The briar thickets there aren’t as wild as they should be. A closer look reveals why.
A small section has been deliberately hollowed out, the thorny branches bent and broken inward to form a crude blind. Rough wooden planks have been laid across the crushed briars, creating a flattened platform just large enough for a couple of small creatures to crouch in relative comfort. From here, anyone inside would have a clear view of the cave approach, the stream, and the narrow dry path—an ideal lookout post. And it’s occupied.

Two goblins lurk inside the blind right now, hunched low, their green skin blending surprisingly well with the shadowed thorns. One idly scratches at its ear with the tip of a dagger. The other chews on something unidentifiable, occasionally glancing toward the cave mouth rather than outward.
They are not paying attention to the surroundings. Lazy guards. Careless.
They have no idea you’re there.
A small section has been deliberately hollowed out, the thorny branches bent and broken inward to form a crude blind. Rough wooden planks have been laid across the crushed briars, creating a flattened platform just large enough for a couple of small creatures to crouch in relative comfort. From here, anyone inside would have a clear view of the cave approach, the stream, and the narrow dry path—an ideal lookout post. And it’s occupied.

Two goblins lurk inside the blind right now, hunched low, their green skin blending surprisingly well with the shadowed thorns. One idly scratches at its ear with the tip of a dagger. The other chews on something unidentifiable, occasionally glancing toward the cave mouth rather than outward.
They are not paying attention to the surroundings. Lazy guards. Careless.
They have no idea you’re there.
OOC:
Alex, what do you do?Feb 9, 2026 10:29 pm
Alex, trusting in his stealth, steals back to Igrem and Nelly, and fills them in on the situation.
OOC:
DM, from M15, can Alex fire his sling and still remain in cover? The rules say: The first attack you make while hidden is made with advantage, then you are no longer hidden. If this attack kills the enemy and no other enemy can see you, you may remain hidden instead. Is that only for melee, or will firing the sling knock me out of cover? From what I recall from the last battle, all the goblins had > 10 HP, which means the possibility of one-shot-kills are low. If there is no way not to be seen, I'd rather set up an ambush where Igrem and Nelly can also get attacks, as 3:2 is a lot better than 1:2 😝Feb 9, 2026 11:07 pm
OOC:
Quote:
Is that only for melee, or will firing the sling knock me out of cover?What do you do?
Feb 9, 2026 11:35 pm
OOC:
OK, @runekyndig,@kwll, do you want to sneak up with me and start a 3 on 2 ambush or do you want to leave the cave unsearched, despite our knowing that the dead horses were those of our employers and non-goblin bodies were dragged this way? I vote for the ambush, as its 3:2 and not 3:5 like it was at the hill.Feb 10, 2026 6:51 am
OOC:
Nelly don't do stealth, but we can use that to our advange here. 1) Alex sneak into posission
2) Nelly comes out the clearing like a normal dupe
3) Goblings attack Nelly in a 2:1 fight (they think)
4) Alex attacks goblins
5) Nelly hides be hinds her shield and charges
Igrem... do some cool magic and save the day
Last edited February 10, 2026 6:51 am
Feb 10, 2026 8:47 pm
OOC:
On the other hand, if Alex gets into position again hidden, he may not only have an attack with advantage, he may have full surprise. I'm not sure which is better. Alex attacking with surprise and the Nelly and Igrem charging in when they hear the noise? Or Nelly coming in and Alex attacking with advantage in his initiative turn given he is hidden. Nimble is a bit light on descriptions (Surprise is page 15 and cover is page 10). Are we allowed to ask you for YOUR opinion, htech, as to what would be more advantageous, considering our characters are not in danger now?Feb 10, 2026 10:15 pm
OOC:
Sure. It's your call, actually. 1. Alex, Nelly and Igrem can start in their previous positions (see map above) and everyone can have 3 actions (a full surprise round, no need to roll). The goblins will likely attack Alex, as you're likely the only threat nearby. Or;
2. You follow Runekyndig's plan, as written, meaning you will have new starting positions (Nelly must start closer) and you should roll Initiative with Advantage to see how many actions you have in your first round. The goblins will surely try to attack Nelly and ignore the party in their first round, as she is "the obvious threat".
Either way, for now, the goblins are considered "Distracted" for the purposes of your Vicious Opportunist ability.
What do you do?
Feb 11, 2026 1:07 am
OOC:
Given we aren't in combat and as Lvl 2 cheat I get move or hide once free per round, even if we take Runekyndig's plan, can I sneak back and start with three full actions with advantage due to MY surprising the goblins once the others come close?Feb 11, 2026 9:19 am
Alex, you use the sound of the stream to mask your final approach.
Keeping low, you slip from tree to tree, then, inch by inch, you position yourself just behind and slightly to the side of the hollowed-out blind. From here, you can see the hunched backs of both goblins through gaps in the woven branches. They still haven’t noticed you.
At that moment, Nelly steps deliberately out from the tree line into the open approach before the cave—shield on her arm, posture alert. She walks forward like a traveler who has simply blundered too close.
The reaction is immediate. Both goblins jerk upright in the blind, eyes widening.
"Tiefling!" one hisses, in Common.
Keeping low, you slip from tree to tree, then, inch by inch, you position yourself just behind and slightly to the side of the hollowed-out blind. From here, you can see the hunched backs of both goblins through gaps in the woven branches. They still haven’t noticed you.
At that moment, Nelly steps deliberately out from the tree line into the open approach before the cave—shield on her arm, posture alert. She walks forward like a traveler who has simply blundered too close.
The reaction is immediate. Both goblins jerk upright in the blind, eyes widening.
"Tiefling!" one hisses, in Common.

OOC:
Ok, Alex can have 3 actions, no need to roll. Nelly, Igrem, please roll Initiative with Advantage. What do you do? Feb 11, 2026 4:32 pm
OOC:
In the words of the late, great Christopher Lee playing Saruman: "TO WAR!"At the risk of dying, given the goblin is distracted, I will use a melee attack with the short sword and set the FIRST attack on G1 to 6. I presume I would have only had advantage on being hidden for the primary die roll, which I am manually setting to 6 due to Vicious Opportunist, and I don't have advantage on either the exploding crits or the sneak attack. If I'm wrong, for the sake of speed, feel free to re-roll. Similarly, please correct any rule misunderstandings I may have made.
As he sinks his sword into the goblin, Alex shouts at the second goblin "You are so ugly that bugbears use you to frighten their children! [Action 2: Create an Opening for Nelly/Igrem on goblin G2. "Increase the next Primary Die Roll against a target by 1 this round"]
Having done what he could to put the second goblin off its timing, Alex decides that popping out of ambush is not only fun, but a life-extending maneuver, and decides to try again [Action 3: Move back to O15]. Plunging into the underbrush, Alex fades from the goblins' sight. [Cheat Lvl 2 Action (Hide):You may either Move or Hide for free].
OOC:
Oof. Awful rolls.Last edited February 11, 2026 4:33 pm
Rolls
Short Sword: Rolling for exploding crits, first attack is crit (+6) - (1d6+2+6, RA)
(1) + 8 = 9
Sneak Attack on crit - (1d6)
(2) = 2
load next


