[Interest Check] [FATE Core] Mystery Point Crawl in a College Setting

Be sure to read and follow the guidelines for our forums.

Oct 5, 2025 7:23 pm
Hi y'all. I'm new to GamersPlane. In fact, this is my very first post. I've written a campaign pitch for a weekly VTT game, but it didn't get off the ground in the end. So, I thought maybe I'd give play-by-post another try. It might take a while for me to actually run it, as I don't know how things work around here yet. Anyway, here's the pitch. Thanks for reading. And have a great rest of your day.
Quote:
You—the PCs—are students at Fargraves Academy, a prestigious university atop a hill in the remote countryside. As founders of the newly established (and relentlessly mocked) detective club, you're waiting for your first case to arrive. Can you manage your student life (and all the drama that comes with it) while uncovering the secrets of Fargraves?

This campaign is about managing your student life, navigating relationships, and uncovering secrets. It's a sandbox of mysteries where you decide which leads to follow. While I'm aiming for a more lighthearted tone, dark themes and subjects are bound to creep in.
Oct 5, 2025 7:25 pm
VTT = Virtual TableTop? Are you recruiting for games not on GamersPlane?
You cant do that.
Oct 5, 2025 7:28 pm
runekyndig says:
VTT = Virtual TableTop? Are you recruiting for games not on GamersPlane?
You cant do that.
No. I was planning on running a weekly game, but it didn't work out. I want to know if anyone here would be interested to play a pbp here based on that pitch.
Oct 6, 2025 12:17 am
I'll make a bold suggestion. Can you move the setting to Japan? Or, more specifically, make it anime?
Oct 6, 2025 6:24 am
Welcome, erkin -- great to see Fate on offer, it doesn't get the love it once did in many RPG spaces. I'm not in the market for another game at the moment, but I'd be patient as you wait for interest -- academy-style games are a favorite for many...
Oct 6, 2025 10:52 am
S.F. says:
I'll make a bold suggestion. Can you move the setting to Japan? Or, more specifically, make it anime?
That thought has never crossed my mind. But it does sound like a fun idea to me. I might end up doing that if the others are interested in it as well.
Oct 6, 2025 10:54 am
Harrigan says:
Welcome, erkin -- great to see Fate on offer, it doesn't get the love it once did in many RPG spaces. I'm not in the market for another game at the moment, but I'd be patient as you wait for interest -- academy-style games are a favorite for many...
Thanks. :)
Oct 6, 2025 3:21 pm
erkin says:
S.F. says:
I'll make a bold suggestion. Can you move the setting to Japan? Or, more specifically, make it anime?
That thought has never crossed my mind. But it does sound like a fun idea to me. I might end up doing that if the others are interested in it as well.
I've been thinking of playing some FATE Core anime, actually. Madoka Magica / Dededede sort of thing. I think it fits detective-bu plot quite nicely.
Oct 6, 2025 5:23 pm
S.F. says:
I'll make a bold suggestion. Can you move the setting to Japan? Or, more specifically, make it anime?
Given that anime is just an æsthetic, is there something specific you're looking forward for with this change? I'm up for playing whether the campaign is set in Fargraves or some Japanese university (though the choice would influence what I'd play). Whether it is 'anime' or not seems mostly a matter of visual æsthetics, since anime is a medium that includes many very different genres and story types.
S.F. says:
I've been thinking of playing some FATE Core anime, actually. Madoka Magica / Dededede sort of thing. I think it fits detective-bu plot quite nicely.
Not familiar with either except by second-hand accounts, but aren't those more occult-actiony and not academic-detective?
Oct 6, 2025 10:50 pm
vicky_molokh says:
S.F. says:
I've been thinking of playing some FATE Core anime, actually. Madoka Magica / Dededede sort of thing. I think it fits detective-bu plot quite nicely.
Not familiar with either except by second-hand accounts, but aren't those more occult-actiony and not academic-detective?
Both are great artsy titles I recommend watching if only to have first-hand knowledge of them. And define "academic detective", because I'm relying strictly on the pitch in OP which fits anime tropes perfectly.
Oct 6, 2025 10:52 pm
S.F. says:
And define "academic detective", because I'm relying strictly on the pitch in OP which fits anime tropes perfectly.
Investigative activities (e.g. figuring out other students' skeletons in the cupboards) within an academic context (an academy, a university, &c.).
Last edited October 6, 2025 10:53 pm
Oct 7, 2025 4:25 am
vicky_molokh says:
S.F. says:
And define "academic detective", because I'm relying strictly on the pitch in OP which fits anime tropes perfectly.
Investigative activities (e.g. figuring out other students' skeletons in the cupboards) within an academic context (an academy, a university, &c.).
And are there any restrictions on what those skeletons in the cupboards might be? What if a student is secretly a magical girl or an extraterrestrial about to bring the end of the world, for example?
Oct 7, 2025 4:53 pm
Surely rumours are pretty wide-ranging. Whether the most outrageous rumours are true probably depends on what kind of setting this is. On the high end of weirdness the world could be like Oddity High (or the recent Youkai Academy), but on the low end it could provide cool social intrigue like in Yakuza Fiancé.
Oct 7, 2025 4:57 pm
...You might want to slow down until erkin can respond. ;)

Welcome, erkin! We're a good community here, and it sounds like your game idea already has some interest!
Oct 7, 2025 4:59 pm
Speaking as someone with no skin in the game, a dark slice-of-life detective game set at the modern day uni and absurdness extravaganza à la Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu sound like two completely different games, for, mostly, two completely different crowds.
Last edited October 7, 2025 4:59 pm
Oct 7, 2025 6:37 pm
cowleyc says:
...You might want to slow down until erkin can respond. ;)

Welcome, erkin! We're a good community here, and it sounds like your game idea already has some interest!
Hey. Thanks. I already like this community. :)
Oct 7, 2025 6:43 pm
reversia.ch says:
Speaking as someone with no skin in the game, a dark slice-of-life detective game set at the modern day uni and absurdness extravaganza à la Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu sound like two completely different games, for, mostly, two completely different crowds.
Good point. The pitch probably should've been more detailed. I'm open to suggestions, but what I had in mind was ordinary people in an ordinary world. Supernatural phenomena, if they occur, will be a shocking revelation. So, PCs are ordinary students, but some rumors might step into the boundaries of the supernatural because, as with real life, some people do believe in it.

Edit: TL;DR: The current iteration of the idea is more of the former and less of the latter.
Last edited October 7, 2025 6:44 pm
Oct 7, 2025 6:57 pm
erkin says:
Good point. The pitch probably should've been more detailed.
That can be important for both the players and yourself - to figure out what you actually want to run.

Starting with a base idea and then building the setting together is fine, but I'd be careful with letting yourself get carried away and steamrolled, trying to please folks, only to suddenly realize that the game shaped out to be one you're not that interested in running/playing.
load next

You do not have permission to post in this thread.