Regroup (OOC)

Jun 22, 2025 4:05 pm
Out of character chatter about Regroup can go here to avoid cluttering up the Roleplay thread.
OOC:
Use the OOC tag in your posts in the Roleplay thread, as needed, to clarify what is happening or suggest Moves.
This is for longer questions and answers related to that Roleplay. Basically: if it needs a back-and-forth, put it here.
General rules questions not answered in the Help! or Resources threads can go in General Chat or here if they are directly related to the RP.

Add a link back to the post in question so we can have context. After posting you can right-click on the orange header and select 'copy link address' (or whatever your browser calls it), then paste that in your OOC post.
Jun 22, 2025 5:18 pm
Ha, I love that Emma just escaped a hell dimension where she was going to be a human sacrifice, leaving her friend behind. Then she doesn’t hear from them, and she’s like, oh well I guess I’ll work on my column. Borderline sociopathic! Brilliant.
Jun 22, 2025 5:19 pm
Also, I should let everyone know, for the next two weeks I will be packing, moving, and unpacking, while also working, so I’ll be busy and tired. Thus I am likely to be a bit slow to reply, but I will do so! Apologies in advance.
Jun 22, 2025 5:29 pm
Drgwen says:
Ha, I love that Emma just escaped a hell dimension where she was going to be a human sacrifice, leaving her friend behind. Then she doesn’t hear from them, and she’s like, oh well I guess I’ll work on my column. Borderline sociopathic! Brilliant.
Gotta stay in character ;)
Jun 22, 2025 5:29 pm
And good luck with your move, hope everything will go smoothly!
Jun 22, 2025 5:47 pm
Delirium says:
(OOC in RP) ... I'm assuming Emma will hear from Benji/Pers eventually? ...
Persephone will only be back on this plane of existence tomorrow night, so you won't hear from her for a day. (large interpretation of 'tomorrow'.) We also don't know where her phone is, so she may have to deal with that, too, before being in contact. If Drgwen is out of contact for a while we can have that resurrection take even longer.

Benji has no phone signal (just like Emma had none till she 'got back and received a flurry of messages'. We don't know how long he will be 'down there', it may be a while, or not long, depending on what happens.
Jun 22, 2025 6:00 pm
In that case, we can pick up when Emma goes back home? She needs to have the conversation with Sarah about moving out; she expected to make some progress on finding a place/job during the weekend.
Jun 24, 2025 6:27 am
It is probably simplest if Emma does not get contacted until after she gets home on Sunday afternoon?
The events happened on Friday night.
Jun 26, 2025 6:17 pm
She lacks the needed respect?! Oh it is ON
Jul 1, 2025 4:09 pm
Actually, @oopsylon, do you want Benji to keep his rat buddies secret and gain a possible advantage from them; or do you want them to be discovered —possibly sparking an indecent— and learn something (or some two things) possibly-significant?
Jul 1, 2025 10:54 pm
I don’t think Benji would make any effort to hide them so let’s say the guards notice the rats as they step forward to take the sword. Tchaikovsky is perched on his shoulder and the other two are sitting in his pockets.
Jul 3, 2025 3:47 am
Just wanna check in with you, @delirium , because my last post was intense. Let me know if it veers to hard into frenemy territory, or is too combative, or just in general makes you uncomfortable, and I’ll revise.
Jul 3, 2025 3:59 am
Don't worry about it! Though you should expect Emma to be combative as well in response
Jul 3, 2025 4:21 am
Drgwen says:
my last post was intense. Let me know if it veers to hard into frenemy territory, or is too combative, or just in general makes you uncomfortable, and I’ll revise.
same goes for you, @Drgwen. Emma does have some narcissist tendencies (I intentionally wrote her like that from the very beginning), though she isn't really one. I dialed back some of the more malignant traits and didn't include others. But she definetly thinks highly enough of herself that it is very hard for her to accept criticism or accountability for her actions, so here we are. Still, I can write something else. She could just think all of it in her head as Pers storms away, without saying it out loud, for instance.
Jul 3, 2025 10:53 pm
Oh no, it’s good! I mean honestly, both of them are hot messes who can be self-absorbed to the point of hurting everyone around them.
Jul 4, 2025 11:34 pm
Drgwen says:
(OOC in RP) ... I assume either from Emma’s own stories or from when she was chatting with him in the evening that she either learned his full name or where he works, or in general enough to get in contact with him (Henry), yes?
Let's leave that up to @Delirium. Henry is a part of Emma's sheet.
Jul 4, 2025 11:39 pm
@oopsylon: If you think Benji may know Alasdair's demonologist [ref], you can Put a Name to a Face [ref] with him. He is Night (vampire). (I don't know his name (or anything beyond what was written) so feel free to add one if you like.)

If you want to try flee, you would need to roll Escape a Situation [ref], but I am not sure I recommend that in your current condition. Up to you, though.
Jul 5, 2025 5:08 am
vagueGM says:
Drgwen says:
(OOC in RP) ... I assume either from Emma’s own stories or from when she was chatting with him in the evening that she either learned his full name or where he works, or in general enough to get in contact with him (Henry), yes?
Let's leave that up to @Delirium. Henry is a part of Emma's sheet.
Leave what up? Do we need his full name (Henry Godfrey), or other details?
Jul 5, 2025 5:56 pm
Delirium says:
vagueGM says:
Drgwen says:
(OOC in RP) ... I assume either from Emma’s own stories or from when she was chatting with him in the evening that she either learned his full name or where he works, or in general enough to get in contact with him (Henry), yes?
Let's leave that up to @Delirium. Henry is a part of Emma's sheet.
Leave what up? Do we need his full name (Henry Godfrey), or other details?
Persephone's ability to contact and associate with Henry. (Behind Emma's back. :)
Jul 5, 2025 6:29 pm
He’s an NPC, so I don’t directly control him. Just keep in mind that since he’s a Relationship, he ‘demand attention, bonds impossible to sever without losing a part of yourself.’ That means that no matter what happens, the Relationships wants, or even demands, Emma’s attention and time ( for whatever reason makes sense for that character). Losing a Relationship (aside from something like the mentioned ‘bullet to the gut’) should happen because Emma pushes them away herself, usually due to her preoccupation with the supernatural. If they stop being a drain on her time by themselves, it kind of defeats the purpose. Not saying it is impossible for them to be lured away, but the playbook assumes they are very seriously invested in Emma.

As for Henry specifically, Emma did warn him not to talk to anyone about what happened, and she told him Persephone is a demon, which I think he came around to accepting, or at least took seriously by the time he left the hotel. Whether they swapped numbers that evening is up to you; Henry wouldn’t usually exchange numbers with a one-night stand, but Pers was very persuasive (mechanically as well), so maybe she talked him into it anyway.
Jul 5, 2025 6:33 pm
Gotcha. Yeah, I wasn’t expecting to "lure him away" or otherwise deny Emma the relationship as much as (a) simply annoy her and (b) see if he knows anything about the organizers of the event, so she can hunt down Choudry. Since she isn’t gonna chat with Emma about it at the moment.

And for the record, I expect Persephone and Emma to mend fences in the not too distant future, but who knows? That depends on how the RP and the dice goes.
Jul 5, 2025 6:51 pm
Cool. So we can say that Persephone and Henry exchanged numbers. Persephone can try getting in contact with him.

Maybe we see how that goes and if that impacts Emma's night?
Jul 5, 2025 7:04 pm
Sounds good. And Persephone wasn’t trying to yell loudly enough for David to overhear in my earlier RP post (ref) but it was something I wanted to make available to @Delirium if they wanted to have David overhear Emma and Pers’s argument. Obviously if preferred, he could have missed it entirely too — it’s up to Delirium!
Jul 5, 2025 7:08 pm
Drgwen says:
... Persephone wasn’t trying to yell loudly enough for David to overhear ...
Based on Emma's frustrated, nostrils flaring, rant, I also have in my notes about David:

• May have overheard talk of demon cult sacrifice [ref] but was a bit feverish at the time.
Jul 6, 2025 11:15 pm
The Demonic Rat Trio (The DRT? The DiRT?) can act independently, but are limited by their form and the situation. What would you have them do? [ref]

We should add them to your sheet, and add the Move as well: We may need to use it if you want to have them help you out.

 • Order Your Underlings: When you order your fiendish underlings to solve a problem, roll with Wild.
  • On a 10+, they follow your instructions precisely and no one can trace them back to you.
  • On a 7-9, either things get messy or you're clearly to blame, your choice.
  • On a miss, they do exactly as they are told and it leads to disaster.
Jul 6, 2025 11:55 pm
I’ve added the move to my playbook (under Moves From Other Playbooks)! Should I add an Order your Underlings roll to my post? I’m not sure if it would be applicable since I’m not sure what a miss or even a partial success would look like in this circumstance as per the move’s description, but I’m happy to roll it if you think it works
Jul 7, 2025 3:02 pm
oopsylon says:
... I’ve added the move to my playbook (under Moves From Other Playbooks)! ...
If you make use of the 'one click dice roller' (roll tables) feature, then also add it to the 'Playbook Moves' section for easy clicking. Up to you.
[ +- ] screenshot


oopsylon says:
... Should I add an Order your Underlings roll to my post? ...
Probably? It sounds like you are giving them an order.
oopsylon says:
... I’m not sure if it would be applicable since I’m not sure what a miss or even a partial success would look like ...
That is always a consideration. This is part of the 'Move Trigger' logic, if the outcomes don't fit the fiction, then the Move is not appropriate. But that is often up to the GM to to find ways for it to fit, the GM knows the situation better and can judge this.

In this case, I easily can see ways for this to get messy (possibly because you are clearly to blame (we don't want to put the consequence on the poor rats, after all:)). All it would take is for them to trigger another alarm, leading to these vampires believing you were trying to do something (escape or play your part in an invasion, probably, depending on how badly it goes and what the follow up is).

The exact, specified wording of the 6- outcome makes it a little hard, but I can make it work with a little creative licence.
oopsylon says:
... I’m happy to roll it if you think it works ...
Yeah. I think it works. Roll it if you are happy with the possible outcomes spitballed above.
Jul 7, 2025 10:07 pm
vagueGM says:
If you make use of the 'one click dice roller' (roll tables) feature, then also add it to the 'Playbook Moves' section for easy clicking. Up to you.
Sure! I’ll do that later.
vagueGM says:
Roll it if you are happy with the possible outcomes spitballed above.
I’ve added the roll to my post! It was a 6 :P
Jul 7, 2025 10:25 pm
oopsylon says:
... It was a 6 :P
Of course it was. :)
Jul 8, 2025 5:29 pm
OK I posted (ref) and used the Silver Tongue move, as you suggested, @vagueGM . I was a bit torn between using the Persuade an NPC move and Figure Someone Out, but I think I want to figure him out first. I get to ask two of the following, and he gets to ask one of me in return.

 • who's pulling your character's strings?
 • what's your character's beef with ˍˍˍˍˍ?
 • what's your character hoping to get from ˍˍˍˍˍ?
 • what does your character worry is going to happen?
 • how could I get your character to ˍˍˍˍˍ?
 • how could I put your character in my Debt?

My two questions are:
(1) How could I get your character to work with me to bring down Choudry?
(2) What is your character hoping to get from Emma?
Jul 8, 2025 6:15 pm
Drgwen says:
... My two questions are:
(1) How could I get your character to work with me to bring down Choudry?
(2) What is your character hoping to get from Emma?
The advantage of Figure Someone Out is that you can know these answers to be true. Otherwise I would say: "too easy." :)
Jul 9, 2025 4:41 am
vagueGM says:
OOC:
We might need a roll, possibly Mislead, Distract, and Trick [ref], and some supporting fiction, depends what you do.
Would In Our Blood be appropriate here? I would describe what Benji said as a ‘subtle falsehood’ as per the move description in the Fae playbook (" You must deceive your target with subtle falsehoods or inventive tricks to trigger In Our Blood; you can't just outright lie to their face or throw a rock to distract them."). He was not directly lying but he was trying to mislead Alasdair with a half-truth.
Jul 9, 2025 2:56 pm
oopsylon says:
... Would In Our Blood be appropriate here? ... a ‘subtle falsehood’ ... a half-truth ...
I am not sure a half-truth counts as a 'subtle falsehood' or 'inventive trick'? You just omitted the part that did not suit you, this sound like any most lies? But, maybe, if that's how you want to define it. (We did comment when you took it that Benji was not a very subtle character.)
oopsylon says:
... as per the move ...
rules says:
In Our Blood: When you mislead, distract, or trick someone from a different Circle through lies of omission or clever misdirection, roll with Heart instead of Mind.
He is of the same Circle as you (Night), so the move should not apply. This is meant for people who don't understand your ways.
Jul 9, 2025 10:11 pm
vagueGM says:
He is of the same Circle as you (Night), so the move should not apply. This is meant for people who don't understand your ways.
Oops! Yep, you’re right! I forgot about that part. I’ll do a regular mislead roll then
oopsylon says:
I am not sure a half-truth counts as a 'subtle falsehood' or 'inventive trick'?
Just for future reference, how would you define a subtle falsehood? I interpreted that as meaning twisting the truth a bit (which is what Benji was doing here) rather than outright lying. If you have a different idea of what that means, it would be good to know that now so I know how to use the move properly in the future
Jul 9, 2025 10:28 pm
An 11! I think in this circumstance, these choices make sense:
• you create an opportunity (to escape? To persuade Alasdair to let him go?)
• you confuse them for some time (the lie is not immediately revealed by the rats returning in front of Alasdair or something)
• you avoid further entanglement (Alasdair thinks the rats are gone and doesn’t worry about them anymore? This one I’m not as sure about… if you don’t think it makes sense I can choose the other option instead)
Jul 10, 2025 7:51 am
oopsylon says:
... Just for future reference, how would you define a subtle falsehood? I interpreted that as meaning twisting the truth a bit (which is what Benji was doing here) rather than outright lying. If you have a different idea of what that means, it would be good to know that now so I know how to use the move properly in the future
I would think it is about more than just lying? It is about 'inventive tricks' and clever ruses. If someone else could just as easily do it by regular Mislead, Distract, or Trick it is just Mislead or Trick or telling lies. Leaving out the details you want to hide is not particularly 'clever' or 'inventive', right? It's the bedrock of all lies.

But, how do you see this as being different to an everyday lie? We did not see anything in the fiction [ref] that involved much obfuscation of the truth at all, it might be debatable if Mislead, Distract, or Trick even triggered, the move is about trying to 'convince someone that the lie you're offering them is the whole truth' [ref], not about the lying itself. We kinda need to see how you convince Alasdair (he wants to believe you, which helps).

Do you think Benji will get much use out of this Move? I can see him growing into it later, but that does mean a change in his ... manner. This isn't just a 'stat substitution' move, it is about the types of lies and trickery the faeries engage in. As the book says:
page 117 says:
This move relies on some degree of imagination and sleight-of-hand, the moment in which your faerie nature leaps to the surface to confound someone with smoke and mirrors.
Is there something else that might fit better? We can talk about a change if need be.
oopsylon says:
... An 11! ...
Great!
oopsylon says:
... • you create an opportunity (to escape? To persuade Alasdair to let him go?) ...
Sure. Show us how this gives you that opportunity to try convince Alasdair to let you go. He is lonely, so getting out of the cell is easier than getting out of his lair (or web:).
oopsylon says:
... • you confuse them for some time (the lie is not immediately revealed by the rats returning in front of Alasdair or something) ...
Yes, it can buy you time, that miss on Order Your Underlings is still incoming, but, if you are lucky, you may be able to get away before it hits?
oopsylon says:
... • you avoid further entanglement (Alasdair thinks the rats are gone and doesn’t worry about them anymore? This one I’m not as sure about… if you don’t think it makes sense I can choose the other option instead) ...
Agreed. The Move only really has impact on the events at play right here and now, not on what might come in the future.
This could be that he dismisses the pocket-demon situation (aiding in the 'letting you out' goal), but it does not mean that it won't come rushing back if the Demon Rat Trio do exactly what you said and find a way through the defences and return to you... at the worst possible time.

How will you navigate the intricacies of hospitality and friendship and social responsibilities while also trying to get away before the other shoe drops? I think that is what we have to see.
Jul 10, 2025 11:33 am
vagueGM says:
But, how do you see this as being different to an everyday lie?
Because everything Benji said was true. It was a lie of omission, as in:
Quote:
When you mislead, distract, or trick someone from a different Circle through lies of omission or clever misdirection, roll with Heart instead of Mind.
I interpreted the move as alluding to the fact that in a lot of folklore, faeries can’t lie so if they want to mislead people they have to be a bit clever and lie without actually lying. Benji was doing exactly that, so I felt it matched the spirit of the move.
vagueGM says:
Is there something else that might fit better? We can talk about a change if need be.
Perhaps. I took the move because Benji does not tend to lie directly or make things up whole cloth, but he does sometimes bend the truth or lie by omission so I thought that fit the move very well. If you don’t think that fits the move then I might need to switch to something else.
Jul 11, 2025 2:49 am
oopsylon says:
... folklore, faeries can’t lie so if they want to mislead people they have to be a bit clever and lie without actually lying. ...
Indeed, that is how I interpret it as well. It does say 'clever misdirection', and the notes specifically call out the need for 'some degree of imagination and sleight-of-hand'.

This is more than just a simple lie of omission. At a minimum you need to actually meet that trigger for Mislead, Distract, or Trick, while also being clever about how you do it. Omitting the salient facts is certainly a part of it.
oopsylon says:
... a bit clever and lie without actually lying. Benji was doing exactly that ...
Fair enough. Maybe make the 'clever' part more apparent in the fiction. We could have run the scene a bit more to set this up if not for the 'other circle' clause.
oopsylon says:
... I took the move because Benji does not tend to lie directly or make things up whole cloth, but he does sometimes bend the truth or lie by omission ...
That's why I found it noteworthy when he took a Move focused on clever lying.
oopsylon says:
... If you don’t think that fits the move then I might need to switch to something else. ...
We can see how it goes. In this case (ignoring the Circle component) I don't think it fit with the fiction we already had. It is not only about the lie of omission, that is only one clause in the Move and supplementary text, the intent is the clever and unexpectedly tricksy ways faeries lie and how hard that are for others to understand.

Benji certainly has a strong element of 'hard to understand', he has shown himself very trusting and honest and even naive in this dark world, so any unexpected lies from him may hit even harder when leveraged against people who know him well?
Jul 11, 2025 2:51 am
oopsylon says:
(OOC in RP) ...
Do we want a Persuade an NPC roll then? (The promise being to spend time with Alasdair)
No need to roll to get him to do what he already wants to do. :)
Jul 11, 2025 4:39 am
vagueGM says:
…while also being clever about how you do it…
I was going more for subtle than for clever, in this case. It’s an ‘or’ in the move, as written, so I don’t really understand why it has to be both a lie of omission AND a clever misdirection in order to qualify. Surely it can be one or the other? Reading both the move itself and the supporting text, it seems to me that the move is intended to be used for two different categories of fae trickery: subtle falsehoods/lies of omission and clever misdirections/inventive tricks. I don’t think it makes sense to say that it has to be both in order to trigger the move.
Jul 11, 2025 5:39 am
oopsylon says:
... I was going more for subtle than for clever ...
Fair enough, that may be where we were not seeing the scene from the same viewpoint. I don't see a huge distinction between 'clever' and 'subtle', and I did not see anything subtle about Benji's not mentioning certain aspects. What exactly was the Misleading, Distracting, or Tricking part that happened from the omission?

As I said, we could (and now I am thinking should) have spent a bit more time on the scene and gotten it to the point where that applied. Next time we can make it work.
Jul 11, 2025 6:46 am
Ah! That might be the root of our confusion. I’ve been taking a ‘subtle falsehood’ to mean the opposite of a boldfaced or outright lie. As in, it was a subtle lie because it was only subtly untrue. But you’re right that subtle can also mean cunning or crafty.

The misleading part was that Benji was trying to mislead Alasdair by implying he sent the rats away because they displeased Alasdair rather than as part of an escape plan.
Jul 13, 2025 1:32 am
This line confused me a bit:
Quote:
"When you speak about not wanting to sleep alone, he calls over a waiter again, deciding to forego the temptation of visiting your place tonight... while he is still sober."
What does this mean? We have three things--Pers speaking of her fear of going to sleep, the idea of visiting her place, and calling over the server. Is he calling over the server to get Pers another drink, rather than leaving for her place? Or is he asking for the check? Or...?
Jul 13, 2025 5:58 am
oopsylon says:
... it was a subtle lie because it was only subtly untrue. ...
I just worry that, without a cunning plan, subtle lies of omission night not have much effect on the fiction. We only roll when both success and failure could be interesting.
oopsylon says:
... implying he sent the rats away because they displeased Alasdair ...
Yeah, that is how I interpreted it after the 3 picks you made. Playing into Alasdair's emotions.
Jul 13, 2025 5:59 am
Drgwen says:
... This line confused me a bit ...
Sorry about that.
Drgwen says:
... Is he calling over the server to get Pers another drink, rather than leaving for her place? Or is he asking for the check? Or...? ...
I had intended it to be 'to get another drink as you asked for'. But if you want Persephone to signal for the bill then that will happen instead.

If Henry gets you too drunk he may be leery of 'taking advantage of you in that state', but if you don't get him a little more tipsy he will be worried about future consequences related to Emma (finding out). It depends a lot on what you, the player, want to have happen.
Jul 13, 2025 6:03 am
@Delirium: I worry we are leaving you out of the action. Do you want to do anything, still, tonight? 'Tomorrow' is Monday, but David is too sick to go to work.

I don't think anything Persephone does will directly impact you in that timeframe, though, and we won't know about Benji till we see how he gets along underground (Benji does not have signal, and may not even have battery anymore).
Jul 13, 2025 6:23 am
vagueGM says:
I worry we are leaving you out of the action.
Yes.
It is a problem.
And Emma isn't going anywhere until David gets better, so she's going to be out of the action longer than just 'tonight'. She will attempt to figure out what happened with Sarah (if anything) the next morning, but other than that, I don't see what else is there for her to do.
Jul 13, 2025 7:22 pm
Delirium says:
... It is a problem.
And Emma isn't going anywhere until David gets better, so she's going to be out of the action longer than just 'tonight'. ...
We could always try get a friend (if you have any;) to sit with him while you do other things. The Relationships are meant to make it hard for you to engage with the action and be a distraction while you do, not to make it impossible and keep you out of the story.
Delirium says:
... She will attempt to figure out what happened with Sarah ...
You let me know how easy you want that to be. How believable you find it will depend largely on Emma's mood.
Jul 13, 2025 7:54 pm
Emma won't get a friend to watch over her sick husband. I just can't picture her doing it. But she also has no interest in tracking down Chaudry, or getting even with him, so I don't see her getting involved with Pers storyline either way, even if she were free to help. What she does care about is figuring out what’s going on with the constant rainstorm, so maybe we can just timeskip a couple of days until David feels better and she’s free to follow that lead?

Also, I was thinking she might try to 'Figure Someone Out' with David. Would the answers still depend on her mood, or could she get some actual information?
Jul 13, 2025 8:12 pm
Delirium says:
... Emma won't get a friend to watch over her sick husband. ...
That's fine, I am sure we can work with that. Such black and white attitudes could make the character harder to keep in the action, but this is your husband, after all, so he is special.
Delirium says:
... I just can't picture her doing it. ...
Is that a player choice? Or is it that you can't see how that would happen? If you want, we can engineer a reason? For instance: your boss could call you in, putting your Relationships in conflict with each other. This could force you to ask a neighbor to pop over for a few hours, for instance.

But we don't need to do that if you want Emma to stay in the flat.
Delirium says:
... But she also has no interest in tracking down Chaudry ...
Using your 'sick husband' as an excuse to avoid that confrontation seems right in line with what we have seen so far. :)
Delirium says:
... What she does care about is figuring out what’s going on with the constant rainstorm, so maybe we can just timeskip a couple of days until David feels better and she’s free to follow that lead?
...
We could start that from the flat, 'tomorrow'. You have the internet, and your stolen data, and such. You are limited in what you can do from home, though (Hit the Streets [ref] requires you to go out and meet people), and what you find may pull you away, forcing a choice (if you, the player, want it).

We can run that scene when you awake?
Delirium says:
... Also, I was thinking she might try to 'Figure Someone Out' with David. Would the answers still depend on her mood, or could she get some actual information? ...
The answers won't depend on your mood, how you interpret them might. Your interpretation and whether you believe people is up to you.

Figure Someone Out [ref] always yields true answers. But what you can ask depends on the situation and the fiction at hand, though. You can't just roll the dice and ask the questions, what you do needs to be able to lead to those answers.

Would any of those questions help Emma with her doubts?

 • who's pulling your character's strings?
 • what's your character's beef with ˍˍˍˍˍ?
 • what's your character hoping to get from ˍˍˍˍˍ?
 • what does your character worry is going to happen?
 • how could I get your character to ˍˍˍˍˍ?
 • how could I put your character in my Debt?

You could... I don't know, this seems radical... just talk to him?
Jul 13, 2025 8:22 pm
vagueGM says:
Is that a player choice?
I meant I can't picture Emma getting someone else to watch over her husband while he is sick, because she would want to take care of him herself. That also means that even if she starts the investigation from home, she won't follow up on any leads that would require her to go outside until David feels better.

For 'Figure Someone Out', I thought she could ask 'what's your character hoping to get from Sarah', or maybe what he is worried is going to happen. I don't think Emma would voice her concerns directly, though, because she doesn't want to accuse her husband of anything he might not have done.
Jul 13, 2025 9:24 pm
Delirium says:
... can't picture Emma getting someone else to watch over her husband while he is sick, because she would want to take care of him herself. ...
I sorta figured as much, which is precisely why I introduced the discovery that you had (unwillingly) done so this past weekend. :)
Delirium says:
... she won't follow up on any leads that would require her to go outside ...
OK. That will limit you... unless you can get people to come to your home?

This also seems like the right time to put a little pressure from your other Relationship. You may have to rebuff Noah Thompson when he calls you into the office.
Delirium says:
... For 'Figure Someone Out', I thought she could ask 'what's your character hoping to get from Sarah' ...
While that technically could hint at an answer about if he was/is tempted, do we want to go that route? On a hit all that happens is that you kill off this plotline that you introduced (and David asks you a question you might not want a answer (about the weekend and who you were with, maybe?)).

You could also get much the same information (without the risk) by talking to your husband. Emma does not know that the information from Figure Someone Out is always true, that is player-facing.
Delirium says:
... I don't think Emma would voice her concerns directly ...
No, in non-mechanical conversation you would need to work around to it, and the Figure Someone Out questions are not asked by your character, of the other character, they are intuited from the interaction.
Jul 14, 2025 3:03 am
I think I said this before, but I do hope Emma and Persephone make up, and I do hope their plots reconnect.

One of the reasons I tend NOT to play Vampire the Masquerade any more is that, almost inevitably, there is no shared game--there are multiple, loosely connected games, one for each PC, spinning their little webs with their own sets of NPCs, with surprisingly little overlap beyond a shared setting and the occasional overarching setting event. Myself, I don't care for games like that, with PCs running entirely unconnected, solo plot lines for extended periods of time. So I do hope that doesn't last too too long in this game.
Jul 14, 2025 3:38 am
@vagueGM: Emma will be somewhat adverse to inviting people to her home after what happened with Pers. Not saying it is impossible, but less likely. We can start the investigation and see how far she reaches before we need to timeskip. For 'Figuring Something Out', I was talking purely OOC as well. Emma would try to feel her husband out, without asking any direct questions about how he feels about Sarah. But if you think it would kill the plotline, we can run the scene without using any Moves.
Jul 14, 2025 3:53 am
@Drgwen: The damage to Emma and Pers’ friendship is likely irreparable. Emma confided in Pers, and Pers not only used that information to hurt her, she did it in Emma’s own home, 'shouting loud enough' for her husband to overhear, and the neighbors! [ref] She's not likely to ever forgive that, and certainly never forget.

That said, Emma is manipulative. I intentionally left a door open, writing that since Pers is useful to Emma, Emma regretted how she handled the situation. [ref]. Meaning Emma would still prefer to pretend like the two of them are still friends, for her own selfish reasons, though she is not likely to ever confide in anything truly personal with her.

I do actually agree with you about PC interaction. I don’t want to split the party or run separate games either. But I think we need to have a meta-level discussion OOC to realign our goals. If we leave it entirely to the characters, I think they’ll just continue to drift apart naturally. So here goes: Emma’s #1 priority for a while now has been investigating the constant rain. She’s been sidetracked by smaller quests, but this has felt like a major, citywide supernatural event for some time. There was even a big gathering about it before you joined the game. I (as a player) really want to get to the bottom of it. It would be a shame if that plotline wraps up without our characters doing anything meaningful with it. Maybe @VagueGM can work Chaudry into it somehow? I think it’s already been hinted that he has some kind of nefarious agenda. That way, either our two quests merge together (and soon!), or Pers could run into Chaudry and get her revenge while helping find a solution to the citywide problem?
Jul 14, 2025 3:15 pm
Delirium says:
@Drgwen: The damage to Emma and Pers’ friendship is likely irreparable. Emma confided in Pers, and Pers not only used that information to hurt her, she did it in Emma’s own home, 'shouting loud enough' for her husband to overhear, and the neighbors! [ref] She's not likely to ever forgive that, and certainly never forget.
Ah that's sad. To be clear, I agree that Persephone was absolutely wrong to do that. I hadn't intended that to be a Rubicon moment, however, only a rupture that would later be repaired. Honestly, I thought we had been on the same page about it, but apparently not. I am sorry I didn't do a better job communicating around that scene.

I'll be honest, that really takes the wind out of my sails for this game. I am not sure if I want to play in a game in which the PCs don't like one another to such an extent that can't ever be overcome. I'll see about forging meaningful relationships with Benji and some NPCs, I guess, and allow Emma to manipulate Pers or a little while. But once Persephone realizes how Emma really feels, she will try to apologize again, but if Emma doesn't accept it, that's basically the end of our character interaction. And that sucks, frankly.

I apologize that my character choices resulted in this.
Jul 14, 2025 3:19 pm
It isn't my intention to sour anyone's enjoyment of this game, and in that spirit, I am willing to make the adjustment and be more amenable toward the two repairing their relationship.
Jul 14, 2025 3:20 pm
And if my in-character actions hurt your feelings, offended you, or hurt your feelings, I am truly and deeply sorry about that. Seriously.
Jul 14, 2025 3:22 pm
No, it's nothing like that! Seriously!
That was purely an IC reaction, and it is a personal fault of mine. I tend to get too much into my character's 'headspace', which isn't always good for the gaming table.
Jul 14, 2025 3:24 pm
Oh good! That's such a relief. Honestly, that makes all of this much less of an issue for me. I had thought I had crossed a line and pissed you off, tbh!

And obv I don't want to force you to do anything that doesn't feel true to Emma. So it might have to be a very long term, campaign goal that the two of them make up. I'm guessing they'll have to go through a lot together and separately and suffer plenty before they are able to.
Jul 14, 2025 3:34 pm
You haven't done anything wrong, nor did you offend me, and I'm truly sorry that I never communicated myself properly.
Emma was definitely hurt, and she's concerned Pers might disrupt her marriage, but that was entirely an IC reaction. I was never offended as a player. I likewise hope that nothing I said or did, IC or OOC made you feel uncomfortable in any way.

I'm open to discussing how Pers and Emma will eventually reconcile, too, which might be better than leaving it to chance.
Jul 14, 2025 3:43 pm
Thanks. I'm good.

My own RP character flaw is that I get bleed between my OOC feelings and my IC PC's feelings. It's weird, too, because I don't get upset when my PCs die, for instance. But a friend rejecting them? Ouch!

So yeah, you're good. No problems. Let's see how these two rather self-destructive girls figure their stuff out, or not!

As for how they might reconcile, I think they will likely have to witness each other really suffering, and perhaps Pers might sacrifice herself for Emma and some point, leading Emma to forgive her. Just a thought, but obv that isn't something I would want to dictate in advance.
Jul 14, 2025 3:46 pm
So I do want to check in with you about Henry. Persephone is torn about what to do with Henry. I was imagining her having a brief romantic dalliance but ultimately realizing that both Per and Henry actually love Emma (as friends). Are you OK with that?
Jul 14, 2025 3:55 pm
Pers saving Emma’s life by diving after her into that gaping pit was enough for Emma to forgive her for showing up at dinner with Henry. That said, I’d rather not plan for Emma to be in another life-threatening situation again 😉 (Though, knowing her...)

Doing her the favor she asked for would help some, because Emma really wants to get David on board with what she's really doing (which is probably not such a good idea, but she doesn't want to keep on hiding the truth from him either)

Regarding Henry; Emma is not interested in him as a romantic partner, so she wouldn't mind it if he and Pers got involved. But putting him in actual danger would annoy her, for her own selfish reasons.
Jul 14, 2025 4:01 pm
OK good to know. And yeah, Persephone thinks she and her bestie just had a fight, not that they aren't friends any more. So she will be apologizing tomorrow, probably, while secretly nursing guilt about whatever happens with Henry. And yes, she will offer to 'inform' David of her true nature too.
Jul 14, 2025 8:03 pm
Sounds like a plan! While it is usually very hard to get Emma to apologize for anything, I think we can make an exception in this case too (as long as Pers extends the olive branch first!). What she said to Pers was pretty nasty.
Jul 14, 2025 8:11 pm
It was, though it was mostly true of course. But still, I felt like they each got in their good shots.
Jul 14, 2025 9:23 pm
Great. Glad you two could work that out.

I, too, would not want to run a game of separate games, this happens from time to time in all urban fantasy games (I have been thinking about a Monster of the Week game using the Team Playbooks from Codex of Worlds (a touring rock band? maybe?), though, even a team, always on the move together, can have interpersonal drama).

I will see about using the Chaudry events to push the characters back together. Maybe remind Emma that Persephone 'was only there to help her' (why else would she be at the hotel and infiltrate the Ivy Club, after all?), and that Persephone chose to risk her life to dive in after Emma (I say 'risk', but she actually lost her life...).

It is hard to be rational about exactly what happened, in what order, the characters don't have access to a written transcript of what was said by whom, so Emma might be in denial about that fact that she was the first to shout about demon sacrifices, and Persephone only continued the 'conversation'... besides, it is hard to be too put out from: "You almost let my husband overhear about 'supernatural stuff'... now, on an unrelated note, could you please prove to my husband about supernatural stuff..." :)

I can link Chaudry's activities to the rain-problem, and even link Viviana back to that as well, if we want. Alasdair is tied to what Chaudry was up to below his lair, as is the hellhound, now, so Benji is thrice-tied to the Chaudry plot.
Jul 14, 2025 9:25 pm
Delirium says:
... Emma will be somewhat adverse to inviting people to her home ... Not saying it is impossible, but less likely. ...
That is a choice, it may limit what you can do. Your character does not always get what they want.
Delirium says:
... before we need to timeskip. ...
A timeskip only exacerbates the problem, if Emma skips forward a week, you will have to wait for the others to catch up, and that week could take months for the players.

Being too hard-nosed about 'will not leave' puts you in tension with your other Relationships, and will cost you. That is a choice you can make. The Relationships are there to complicate your life.
Delirium says:
... For 'Figuring Something Out', if you think it would kill the plotline, we can run the scene without using any Moves. ...
Rolling a hit on Figure Someone Out and getting answer will immediately answer the question... Emma needing to know what is going on there is the whole plotline, no? Unless you choose to ignore the facts that are presented by your Figuring Him Out and continue to be suspicious there is nothing else there, your trust of your husband (or lack thereof) is a plotline you brought into the story, so you are welcome to put it to bed anytime you want. Using the Moves might mean you can't get satisfactory answers if you roll low, using the fiction means you can't ever know for sure, but we are in control of what you learn, at the pace you choose.

Are we in a hurry to end this line? Say the word and the 'laundry' situation can be resolved in a trice.
Jul 14, 2025 9:26 pm
Delirium says:
... Regarding Henry; Emma is not interested in him as a romantic partner, so she wouldn't mind it if he and Pers got involved. But putting him in actual danger would annoy her, for her own selfish reasons.
And you, the player, are happy with Persephone getting romantically involved with one of your Relationships? He is already 'in danger' due his newfound enmity with the Ivy Club and his disruption to their plans (you asked for him to be entangled with a demon cult:).

He is still reticent to go out and sleep with your 'friend', but that is easily overcome. If it happens, should they keep it secret from Emma?
Jul 14, 2025 9:32 pm
Also, just to be clear, Persephone was not trying to raise her voice enough for David to hear. She just happened to get upset and raise her voice. It was I, the player, who pointed out that her voice was loud enough to be heard. So Persephone was not trying to mess with Emma‘s marriage.

If that didn’t come across on the text, I apologize. That was my intention.
Jul 14, 2025 9:34 pm
That was how I interpreted it, both for Persephone's 'reply' and for Emma's initial 'raised voice' before that.

Whether he (or the neighbours) overheard anything is up to us.
Jul 15, 2025 4:16 am
vagueGM says:
your trust of your husband (or lack thereof) is a plotline you brought into the story, so you are welcome to put it to bed anytime you want.
Emma wasn't distrustful until the 'laundry' post [ref], which was phrased in an almost unambiguous way (she must have been intimately 'taking care' of him). She was angry at Sarah before because she felt she was being too familiar with her husband, but didn't suspect him of anything till then. At any rate, since this is important for Emma, she will try 'looking into his heart' and discern what she can. I'm impartial toward ending this plotline now or continuing it, so might as well see how it plays out.
Drgwen says:
It was I, the player, who pointed out that her voice was loud enough to be heard. So Persephone was not trying to mess with Emma‘s marriage.
That is something they can discuss when they next meet. Emma expected more discretion from Pers. Loud or not, it is still a bad idea to talk about Emma 'drapping herself over any man who could benefit her this weekend, including her ex', AND saying she doesn't love her husband....while her husband is sleeping in bed right across the hall. Loud or not, Emma is already pissed about that, and that's disregarding that it was hurtful. It's not talking about 'demons', that set her off, but the complications Pers can cause to her marriage.
vagueGM says:
And you, the player, are happy with Persephone getting romantically involved with one of your Relationships?
We ARE talking about Henry, right? Just making sure! ;)

As a player, I'm fine with anything. Emma will be fine with Henry, specifically, and Pers hooking up, since she isn't interested in him romantically. If Pers however, puts him in danger, then Emma will be very cross with her, to the point she might do something very vindictive .It doesn't matter if Henry is actually in danger right now due to his past involvement with the Ivy club, because Emma believes he isn't after she confronted Sinclair. For sure, 'getting revenge' on the club and haunting down Chaudry, would force their hands either way to deal with him, so I think, OOC as well, that this plotline DOES put him in much more danger.
Jul 15, 2025 6:47 am
Hmm I tried to edit Benji’s sheet and I somehow appear to have deleted it :/

I will have to fix it later when I have time and access to my computer. Sorry about that
Jul 15, 2025 7:05 am
Delirium says:
... phrased in an almost unambiguous way ...
Oops. Was not meant to unambiguous, just suggestive. I can see several interpretations and reasons for those facts.

We can clear it up quite quickly if you want to put it behind you.
Delirium says:
... might as well see how it plays out. ...
No problem. Let's see how it goes. If you want to use Moves, go for it; if you want to use dialogue, we can do that; if you want something like obvious answers ex machina, I can provide that too.
Delirium says:
... talk about Emma 'drapping herself over any man ...
Yeah, and there is a police case stating that you were at a hotel with another man...
Delirium says:
... AND saying she doesn't love her husband... ...
Yeah... that was out out line. :)
Emma seems lacking in empathy, so I don't suppose it will help to say 'picture it from Persephone's point of view'? :)
Delirium says:
... We ARE talking about Henry, right? Just making sure! ;) ...
Er... yes. Though you boss is a lonely man... ;)
Delirium says:
... this plotline (revenge) DOES put him in much more danger. ...
Or take out the danger. But, we will keep him safe from that, it should be your actions that doom your Relationships, not that of the other PCs (hence my asking your permission for the hookup, at each level).
Jul 15, 2025 7:05 am
Never mind, it’s all good! I rescued him from the staging server. I’ll have to put the Order Your Underlings move back in there but other than that I think it’s all fine
Jul 15, 2025 7:06 am
oopsylon says:
Hmm I tried to edit Benji’s sheet and I somehow appear to have deleted it :/ ...
Any idea how you did that? Is it still the bug where you hit Save twice?
oopsylon says:
... I rescued him from the staging server. ...
It is useful having that around. :)
Jul 15, 2025 7:34 am
vagueGM says:
Any idea how you did that? Is it still the bug where you hit Save twice?
I think so! I was going to add the corruption to my sheet, instinctively pressed edit, remembered that I don’t need to edit the sheet to mark corruption and so pressed save and exit to exit edit mode. I realised after I pressed save that the sheet hadn’t loaded in properly yet but it was too late :/
Jul 15, 2025 7:50 am
oopsylon says:
... instinctively pressed edit, remembered that I don’t need to edit the sheet to mark corruption and so pressed save and exit to exit edit mode. ...
The back button would generally be a better way to leave the edit screen.
oopsylon says:
... I realised after I pressed save that the sheet hadn’t loaded in properly yet but it was too late :/
Keleth was going to look into this, but I don't think anything has been done yet. Maybe report the problem and your detailed description of the cause so it can move up on the bug roster.

You can add your report to the existing one: Character Sheet Gone.
Jul 15, 2025 7:53 am
vagueGM says:
The back button would generally be a better way to leave the edit screen.
Yeah it was dumb in retrospect but it was just sort of a split-second muscle memory thing I did without thinking :P
Jul 15, 2025 8:06 am
vagueGM says:
No problem. Let's see how it goes.
Should I start the next scene? If so, I would need to know how sick David is the next day. If he is still running a high fever, Emma will take him to the hospital rather than try to interrogate him (and a hospital visit is not a scene I am interested playing in detail).
vagueGM says:
hence my asking your permission for the hookup, at each level
I hope 'dooming her relationship by her actions' would entail more than giving her ex 'permission' to hook up with whomever he feels like?
Jul 15, 2025 4:05 pm
As I tried to indicate in my post, Persephone is not looking for sex right now, nor really to get back at Emma, so much as simple human comfort. She has been very badly traumatized and was hoping to find support from Emma, but , well, we all know how that went! She's hurting right now, and you know what they say: hurt people hurt people. I imagine if Per and Henry do end up in bed together, she is more likely to ask to be held and immediately fall asleep than anything more explicit. But we shall see!
Jul 16, 2025 3:24 am
Persephone is not going to initiate intimacy with Henry. But she will carelessly flirt and make herself available, so to speak, allowing herself to be used if it happens, by anyone who would like to, frankly. If he (or someone else here) does make a move, how it happens will likely determine whether she goes along with it or not. If no one does, she will simply try to fall asleep in someone's arms, even if they remain fully clothed.

The poor girl has just been brutally assaulted and then went to hell, after all; she is dissociating, drunk, and desperate for anything to provide some comfort and solace.

PS This sort of reaction is in line with my own personal experience coping with PTSD, but please let me know if my RPing it makes anyone uncomfortable.
Jul 19, 2025 2:17 am
oopsylon says:
(OOC in RP) ...Should I roll Persuade an NPC? It’s sort of a mix of promises (I’ll send the rats back up and we can keep talking and playing scrabble) and threats (if you hurt the rats, we won’t be friends anymore)
It seems a bit weak? I think Alasdair might need more than just a the promise of a little socialisation?

But roll it and we can see, maybe, on a very high roll, he is that desperate that he will compromise his beliefs and possibly his position for your company? But this will also mean a demand for your valuable company going forward. On a 7-9 he will demand much more, but we will need to work out what that is (possibly in play), since we don't want to take you out of the story by forcing you to stay down here for a while or have come down here regularly.
Jul 19, 2025 4:22 am
I am still torn in this scene between them actually having sex and them just falling asleep together. I know I wanted to complicate her relationship with Circe, and behave in a way that leads her to begin to understand how traumatized she is. And I would like to have her and Henry continue to have sexual tension when they aren't drunk, and have them still be able to cooperate in going after the Ivy Club and Choudry. But all of those things are the consequences the day after and beyond. I am not sure what to do about the present moment here! Any suggestions for what feels right for the characters, could make a good scene, could increase the drama, could be fun, etc?
Jul 19, 2025 5:39 am
The last sentence of your RP post already suggests sex isn't on Pers mind, to the point that if Henry initiates something, he would look more like a sexual predator. Which wouldn't have been out of character for him, the way I originally envisioned him, but he has obviously 'matured' some, and now I can't picture him doing it (this is the same guy that ran out of the hotel room because he couldn't stand being around Emma in a bathrobe, yes?)
Jul 19, 2025 6:00 am
Drgwen says:
(OOC in RP) ]Oops, I didn't quite realize Edward was that much older...oh well, it stands as is! Persephone is an even worse person than I had intended. Again!
He wasn't... until he became such, as a result of your goading Circe with him being an inappropriate date. :)
It also might be a bit of an exaggeration, he is probably only, like, forty? :)
Drgwen says:
... I am still torn in this scene between them actually having sex and them just falling asleep together. ...
I had not pictured Henry as drunk enough to be falling asleep in a stimulating situation like this, but if you do, he will have to make do.
Drgwen says:
... I know I wanted to complicate her relationship with Circe ...
What you do ... or don't do... in the privacy of your own bedroom is none of her business... which is another way to say: she will assume you did, anyway. Explaining to her: "We did not have sex! We just slept in the same bed... yes, OK, naked..." could be a cute-but-unbelievable story. :)
Drgwen says:
... I would like to have her and Henry continue to have sexual tension ...
I don't think a night of ill-advised, drunken copulation will do much to reduce any linger sexual tension... it could add to it.
Drgwen says:
... But all of those things are the consequences the day after and beyond. ...
If you want, you can cuddle for a bit and then fall asleep before anything happens.

Do you want to have an awkward scene in the morning, when you both wake up naked in bed, possibly unsure of exactly what happened, but pretty sure it did not go all the way? Or is he gone when you wake up? (... and did he have a conversation with Circe while sneaking out?:).
Drgwen says:
... Any suggestions for what feels right for the characters ...
For your character: I think sleep and no sex seems right. We can make that happen.

I would think this whole night (no matter what happens in the bedroom) triggers your Intimacy Move, but, as No-Status nobody, he has no Debts, so there is not mechanical effect.
Drgwen says:
... still be able to cooperate in going after the Ivy Club and Choudry. ...
Can do.
Jul 19, 2025 6:01 am
Delirium says:
The last sentence of your RP post already suggests sex isn't on Pers mind, ...
Really? I interpreted that exactly the opposite way.
Persephone says:
"Come to bed, hon, mommy's sleepy..."
Try that with a gender tweak: "Come to be honey, daddy's sleepy"... Um, yeah, implication there?
Delirium says:
... to the point that if Henry initiates something, he would look more like a sexual predator. ...)
He isn't going to, but I hardly think 'sexual predator' of a guy who has just been tasked with helping a girl take her clothes off.
Jul 19, 2025 6:09 am
'Sleepy' doesn't sound sexy nor inviting to me, personally, but I guess it's just my own bias coming through.
Jul 19, 2025 6:09 am
Agreed... but coupled with everything else in the scene it sure is ambiguous...
Jul 19, 2025 8:59 pm
Persephone has been reveling in the flirting and ambiguity as a way to make herself feel good. But now there can be no more ambiguity, and she is drunk enough to make poor decisions, or to pass out and obviate them. I've been waffling a bit, but I think she would have sex with him if she doesn't pass out. I think she has put herself in a situation where that seems just to be the natural thing to happen next, and she might just go along with it.
Delirium says:
The last sentence of your RP post already suggests sex isn't on Pers mind, to the point that if Henry initiates something, he would look more like a sexual predator. Which wouldn't have been out of character for him, the way I originally envisioned him, but he has obviously 'matured' some, and now I can't picture him doing it (this is the same guy that ran out of the hotel room because he couldn't stand being around Emma in a bathrobe, yes?)
Yeah, I don't think he is one.
vagueGM says:
Drgwen says:
(OOC in RP) ]Oops, I didn't quite realize Edward was that much older...oh well, it stands as is! Persephone is an even worse person than I had intended. Again!
He wasn't... until he became such, as a result of your goading Circe with him being an inappropriate date. :)
It also might be a bit of an exaggeration, he is probably only, like, forty? :)
ha! Well played.
Drgwen says:
... I know I wanted to complicate her relationship with Circe ...
I mean more generally with showing up drunk and embarrassing her (twice--don't forget her nude appearance!).
vagueGM says:
I don't think a night of ill-advised, drunken copulation will do much to reduce any linger sexual tension... it could add to it...
Do you want to have an awkward scene in the morning, when you both wake up naked in bed, possibly unsure of exactly what happened...
I think this is hilarious and Yeah we should do this.
vagueGM says:
For your character: I think sleep and no sex seems right. We can make that happen.
I actually agree, but that's why I think it should happen. She will recognize she is acting wildly out of character and move to address it. And have a bigger mess to clean up.
Jul 21, 2025 4:08 am
Drgwen says:
... don't forget her nude appearance! ...
I don't think anyone there will ever forget that... and Circe is unlikely to ever let you forget it. :)
Drgwen says:
vagueGM says:
... sleep and no sex seems right. We can make that happen.
I actually agree, but that's why I think it should happen. ... ...
Are you going to make that scene happen? You are in the driver's seat and Henry will take what he can get.
I admit I am confused by 'but that's why I think it should happen' in the context of 'no sex'... should the sex happen... or should the 'no sex' happen... it is up to you. :)
Jul 21, 2025 4:19 am
vagueGM says:
I admit I am confused by 'but that's why I think it should happen' in the context of 'no sex'... should the sex happen... or should the 'no sex' happen... it is up to you. :)
well, she is acting uncharacteristically, because she is traumatized. So if your sense of her character is that she would not, then in this case she would, as a sign of her imbalance.

I dunno… it makes sense to me? What can I say? It is as Walt Whitman said:
"Do I contradict myself?
Very well then I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.)"
Jul 21, 2025 4:22 am
Do you want me to post again? I was assuming that you would have Henry’s initial reaction first. But I can narrate it if you’d prefer.
Jul 21, 2025 4:25 am
Drgwen says:
... "Do I contradict myself? ...
I am not concerned about the contradiction. I just don't know which way the answer fell. Whether 'it should happen' is the falling asleep or the sex.
Drgwen says:
... Do you want me to post again? ...
By all means, if you can.
Drgwen says:
... I was assuming that you would have Henry’s initial reaction first. ...
His reaction is the predictable one of a man in such a situation, with the caveats we discussed of him being a gentleman and not forcing you to do anything.
Drgwen says:
... But I can narrate it if you’d prefer. ...
Please do, I am not sure where you want to take the scene. You can do with what you like, the NPCs are easy (are you?:).
Jul 23, 2025 5:58 pm
I was torn between focusing on the awkwardness of the morning and the internal trauma she’s wrestling with. I went mostly trauma with a bit of awkward. And I kept with the "dissociation/depersonalization autopilot" thing which results in just doing what others want you to do and paying no mind to your own needs.
Jul 24, 2025 11:53 am
It made me a bit sad reading it :(
Jul 25, 2025 3:26 am
Delirium says:
It made me a bit sad reading it :(
Yeah, trauma responses are sad. At least, that's what I was going for.

And poor Henry. Pity is definitely not a good basis for a relationship. And thinking "he tries, like a puppy" isn't either!
Jul 25, 2025 6:02 am
Drgwen says:
... Yeah, trauma responses are sad. ...
As they are meant to be.
Drgwen says:
... At least, that's what I was going for. ...
It was subtle, but there. Very nice stuff.
Drgwen says:
... And poor Henry. ...
Yeah, well, if Emma is to be believed the 'poor man' has enough 'relationships' to be going on with... He will get over it?
Jul 27, 2025 8:24 am
Wow! The dice are not being kind to poor Benji
Last edited July 27, 2025 8:24 am
Jul 27, 2025 12:38 pm
oopsylon says:
Wow! The dice are not being kind to poor Benji
Those poor, poor dice and that kind, kind Benji. :)
oopsylon says:
(OOC in RP) ... but I’m fine with either outcome.
As it should be. If we ever aren't, then we talk before we roll.

I don't think we go full HARD Move, just yet; splashing images of Benji's rampage all over the news and needing someone (one of the other vampire factions, probably) to step in and stop him... but, if you roll another bloody miss on Eternal Hunger (Blood) then we may end up there.

I think it is a 'rail maintenance worker' and they are not as alone as we thought? So, either way, you get spotted... (or get another meal? Depends on how you look at it?:)

Do you want to narrate your coming up on the worker and what you do, including a roll, then make your picks.

If you get to choose, and choose 'they don't die' (what's the wording? 'They don't suffer 3 Harm'), then you can choose how you are discovered, if you can't pick that option they either die here or are rushed to hospital where there is a 50/50 they die anyway. You really need to heal a lot to get over the Hunger, and a +1 Forward could apply to the next feeding or to avoiding the next feeding, so a kill here might be the neatest? On a miss, you are caught red-handed, and messy, the Hunger driving you further.
Jul 28, 2025 1:29 am
A success! On a 10+ I get all 3:
  • You heal 1-harm or take +1 forward (I'll choose to heal 1 harm)
  • You learn a secret about your prey
  • Your prey doesn't suffer 3-harm (ap)
Last edited July 28, 2025 1:31 am
Jul 28, 2025 11:10 am
oopsylon says:
... A success! On a 10+ I get all 3: ...
Finally! :)
oopsylon says:
... • You heal 1-harm or take +1 forward (I'll choose to heal 1 harm) ...
Cool, I see you marked that, one more and you can clear that whole Serious, broken rib issue, and the Faint can heal over time.
oopsylon says:
... • You learn a secret about your prey ...
You have anything in mind for a 'random rail worker'? Maybe something about a 'true hunger' that you can help them indulge in?
oopsylon says:
... • Your prey doesn't suffer 3-harm (ap) ...
Great, how do you restrain yourself, or does something intervene?
Do you want to describe that restraint and how you get found by the other mealworker... and what you do to the person who finds you, or should I take it from here?
Jul 28, 2025 11:31 am
vagueGM says:

You have anything in mind for a 'random rail worker'? Maybe something about a 'true hunger' that you can help them indulge in?
Sure, that's a good idea! The only other thought I had was some sort of secret connection to the supernatural? Might be a bit too much of a coincidence though...
vagueGM says:

Do you want to describe that restraint and how you get found by the other mealworker... and what you do to the person who finds you, or should I take it from here?
You can take it from here, if you like!
Jul 28, 2025 12:33 pm
oopsylon says:
... The only other thought I had was some sort of secret connection to the supernatural? Might be a bit too much of a coincidence though...
Given the proximity to the dog stuff and Alasdair's lair entrance we can make it work if you prefer that.
Jul 28, 2025 12:34 pm
vagueGM says:
oopsylon says:
... The only other thought I had was some sort of secret connection to the supernatural? Might be a bit too much of a coincidence though...
Given the proximity to the dog stuff and Alasdair's lair entrance we can make it work if you prefer that.
I'm happy with either, so feel free to go with whatever idea you find most interesting!
Jul 29, 2025 1:52 pm
vagueGM says:
oopsylon says:
(OOC in RP) Persuade an NPC?
With? What? Threats?

So far as this poor fella knows you just murdered his buddy, for no reason, and you have blood on your face. Threatening him might just reinforce his fear rather than calm him, don't we think?

Are you sufficiently 'in control' that you can reason with him and be reasoned with? You still have Serious Wounds and a Hunger that 'fridge blood' won't sate. Up to you, though.
I swear I posted that in this OOC thread... oops.
oopsylon says:
... The promise not to bite him ...
Why would he believe that. Consider the scene from his perspective.
oopsylon says:
... I figured worker #1 might not be willing to cooperate if Benji murders his friend. ...
And quite rightly so.

I would like for us to find a way for you to use your newfound secret, but the Move is not mind-control, the proportions need to be in accord.

"Wait! I know it looks like I just ate your friend/colleague, but if you just wait and talk you might make it out alive" can only buy you so much, it might cause him to hesitate long enough for you to get an opportunity, but even a 10+ won't get him trusting you enough to take his hand off his radio?

What you do next will still have the risk of this being called in, with the added risk of him also having more time to prepare.

If you are happy with that: Roll it and we can see?
oopsylon says:
... If he continues to reach for the radio, Benji is just going to tackle him and bite him too. ...
If you decide not to roll, he will try radio this in, you will get a chance to try stop him (maybe by getting to him before he can report in?).
Jul 29, 2025 1:58 pm
vagueGM says:
Why would he believe that. Consider the scene from his perspective.
It’s less that I think he would trust Benji and more that he doesn’t have a lot of other options...
But fair enough. I’ll have Benji bite him and roll Eternal Hunger again instead.
Jul 29, 2025 2:12 pm
oopsylon says:
(OOC in RP) ... Shall I roll Eternal Hunger or do I need to make a different roll first to set that up and stop him using the radio (Keep Your Cool maybe?)?
Since you did not really give him the time (by trying to Persuade) we can assume you make it to him in time. Roll your Hunger.
Jul 29, 2025 9:59 pm
I added the roll to my post! It was a 9 so I’ll choose to heal 1 harm and not do 3 harm
Jul 30, 2025 11:05 am
oopsylon says:
I added the roll to my post! It was a 9 so I’ll choose to heal 1 harm and not do 3 harm
Excellent. That is actually a surprisingly forgiving Move. That means he lives, which will help your case.
Jul 30, 2025 11:06 am
Delirium says:
(OOC in RP) ... I added the roll on my previous post, because I wanted to see how it would come up first before writing. ...
Perfect.
Delirium says:
(OOC in RP) ... It was an 11, so I'm going with Dead-Beat owing Emma a favor. ...
Great. You won't need to use the favour to get in, but it might be useful later, depending on how the scene goes.
Delirium says:
(OOC in RP) ... Also marking 'night' at last! ...
Yeah, that was the plan. I could not see a way to get Wild involved without some convoluted hoop-jumping... but they are on the board for you as well.
Jul 30, 2025 11:11 am
@vagueGM, Emma is going to ride the elevator up to the penthouse. May I describe the scene as she enters (general mayhem, basically)?
Jul 30, 2025 11:11 am
Delirium says:
... May I describe the scene as she enters (general mayhem, basically)?
Go for it.
Jul 30, 2025 12:13 pm
@oopsylon: Do you have any ideas about who these guys are? Machetes make me think 'vampire hunters', which could be interesting, but does complicate your life... what with you being a vampire, and someone who is public in the transit system.

Whoever they are, making them Mortalis would let you roll to see if your know anything about them and net you an Advance.
Jul 30, 2025 12:22 pm
I was thinking amateur monster hunters/investigators sort of thing. They've seen things they can't explain in the course of working underground and have started to dig a little deeper, but maybe don't fully understand what they're getting themselves into just yet.

In any case, I'll add a Put a Name to a Face roll to my last post.
Jul 30, 2025 12:30 pm
8! So Benji knows them by reputation. Maybe he's heard rumours there's a couple guys on the maintenance crew who are really into the 'urban legend' stuff and seem to take it pretty seriously?
Jul 30, 2025 12:37 pm
More importantly, I get to advance! I've had my eye on Bloodhound from the Wolf Playbook for a while, but I also think Terrifying from the Vamp playbook could be fitting given the circumstances of the advance as well as the whole ordeal leading up to this (although 'terrifying' is not exactly the vibe Benji wants to give off...). What do you think?
[ +- ] Bloodhound
[ +- ] Terrifying
Jul 31, 2025 8:35 am
oopsylon says:
... amateur monster hunters ...
Yeah, I also thought 'monster hunters', rather than specifically 'vampire'. Maybe they don't know enough details to be 'vampire hunters' and your politeness may confuse them about what constitutes a 'monster'. :)

oopsylon says:
... More importantly, I get to advance! ...
That's a thing that happens in this game? :)
oopsylon says:
... I've had my eye on Bloodhound from the Wolf Playbook for a while ...
I haven't looked through the other options, but that one sounds interesting.

Terrifying does not really fit with Benji so far, but if you want to show how his recent experiences changed him, this might be a good time to take it? The names have meaning, they are not just stat-bumps. :)

Bloodhound will benefit from Terrifying, but increasing your Blood first seems boring (unless it is accompanied by the aforementioned changes?). You can always take that later as you get better...

Advances are rare enough that taking a stat boost to benefit a Move you want might see you better at that stat, but never getting that Move, might be best to take the Move and hope to get better at its stat later?

Don't forget to Mark Corruption for feeding from these two people by force. Do we count this as 'one time', or are they each a Corruption?
Jul 31, 2025 8:53 am
vagueGM says:
…Terrifying does not really fit with Benji so far…
Yeah, I agree. ‘Twas just a thought. I think I’ll take Bloodhound then
vagueGM says:
Don't forget to Mark Corruption for feeding from these two people by force. Do we count this as 'one time', or are they each a Corruption?
Already done! I marked them both separately
Jul 31, 2025 3:47 pm
Delirium says:
(OOC in RP) Can I roll 'Let it Out' to find a hidden clue?
Sure, you could also think about rolling Study a Place of Power [ref] (instead or as a possible followup aided by your clue).
Jul 31, 2025 3:50 pm
I went with 'Let it Out'. Study a Place of Power is also suitable, but Emma is less interested in Dead-Beat and his cronies right now.
Managed a '7', so if the choice is up to me, I would go with success with a cost. Emma finds an important clue, but she is also caught red-handed by Dead-Beat's vampire girlfriend.
Jul 31, 2025 4:14 pm
Delirium says:
... success with a cost. Emma finds an important clue, but she is also caught red-handed by Dead-Beat's vampire girlfriend.
Sounds good. You can show us what you find and then how you are caught by the girlfriend (and maybe hint as to how she got Dead-Beat to not be here).

Do you know her? Want to roll for it? Or is she too new? Feel free to give her a name, either way.
Aug 4, 2025 2:31 pm
Delirium says:
(in RP) ... "I’ll owe you a debt if you let me leave. ..."
It feels a little weird to offer a Debt out load like that, but I suppose these people understand that in-world mechanic (even if Emma does not seem to :), so it may be talked about like that.

Mechanically it is tricky, Tara does not care about 'Debts later', so you would need to Persuade her to put off her fun, but it could get messy if you miss and even on a 7-9 it could get messy.

If you want to take the risk, both of rolling and of owing someone like this a Debt, maybe roll Persuade [ref] (or something else if you can think of something else) and we can see if she accepts.
Aug 4, 2025 2:58 pm
vagueGM says:

It feels a little weird to offer a Debt out load like that
Sorry. Pretend Emma said something like she would be in her debt, or something of the sort.
I don't imagine Tara would care about 'debts later' either, so the Persuade move might not be triggered at all!
She, Dead-Beat, strike me as impulsive.

I'm going to roll 'figure someone out' instead, hoping I can get a lead on what it would take for her to let Emma leave.
Does that sound suitable?
Aug 4, 2025 3:00 pm
Or maybe 'let it out' by appealing to convince her to act on her 'kindness, role, or own best interest'?
Aug 4, 2025 3:20 pm
Delirium says:
... She, Dead-Beat, strike me as impulsive. ...
That was the impression I got, too.
Delirium says:
... roll 'figure someone out' instead, hoping I can get a lead on what it would take for her to let Emma leave. ...
That could work.
Delirium says:
... Or maybe 'let it out' by appealing to convince her to act on her 'kindness, role, or own best interest'? ...
Not sure her 'kindness' applies. :) Nor her 'role'. But you may be able to find a way to leverage her 'own best interest', but you will need to work out what those are... so maybe after the Figure Someone Out?
Aug 4, 2025 3:38 pm
I rolled 7 on 'figure someone out'. So I'm thinking the obvious 'how could I get your character to allow me to leave?', plus - 'how could I put your character in my Debt?'
Aug 4, 2025 3:42 pm
Delirium says:
I rolled 7 on 'figure someone out'. So I'm thinking the obvious 'how could I get your character to allow me to leave?', plus - 'how could I put your character in my Debt?'
How do you glean these answers? What you learn needs to be backed up in the fiction, so you may need to talk some more. I can steer the conversation towards answers if you can't.
Delirium says:
(in RP) ... She really hoped there was something more than that. She tried reading it in her body posture, but the longer she looked at her, the more she started to worry that what she was seeing was all there was.
Do you have something you would like? Or is what we see what we get?
How much would Emma be willing to give? How much are you willing to make her give?
Aug 4, 2025 3:50 pm
vagueGM says:
Do you have something you would like? Or is what we see what we get?
She doesn't strike me as a planner, and neither does Dead-Beat. I intended them more as a symbol of the Chaos left behind after Eliot's disappearance. I think Emma would have an uncomfortable choice to make, but what I know for sure she won't willingly offer is anything sexual. She's still loyal to her husband.
Aug 4, 2025 3:56 pm
Delirium says:
... I think Emma would have an uncomfortable choice to make ...
Yep. :)
Delirium says:
... but what I know for sure she won't willingly offer is anything sexual. ...
OK. They may want and hope for that, and you can dangle that prospect as a lure, but you are always in charge of it if goes there.

Maybe blood, and a fun time like you showed Dead-Beat? (so: demands on your time... and 'not, like, next week' they don't look that far ahead. :)

You might be able to appeal to her own best interests and offer her 'regular blood, but on your term' rather than a one off now which could be messy?
Aug 4, 2025 4:00 pm
vagueGM says:
They may want and hope for that,....Maybe blood, and a fun time like you showed Dead-Beat?
Likely, considering there is already a party going on right there in the living room. Let's see where it leads.
Aug 4, 2025 5:14 pm
I went for the first option, and rolled an '8'. So getting by the skin of her teeth, more or less
Aug 4, 2025 6:32 pm
Delirium says:
I went for the first option, and rolled an '8'. So getting by the skin of her teeth, more or less
'teeth in your skin'?

The end result may be slightly like a middling Escape a Situation and you may owe someone for helping you, but you would need to be reminded of that.

I don't think the security went into the penthouse... that would cause a ruckus ... but you could also avail yourself of his services if you want him to help you.
Aug 4, 2025 6:42 pm
Delirium says:
(in RP) ... pants ...
I am also assuming that when you say 'pants' you mean American pants and not British pants...
Correct me if I am wrong and lucky Tara (and everyone else) gets a higher rated show.
Aug 4, 2025 8:34 pm
vagueGM says:
I am also assuming that when you say 'pants' you mean American pants
Umm...yes. She would have no reason to take off her panties.
Aug 4, 2025 8:41 pm
That's what I thought.
Aug 5, 2025 6:39 pm
Oof, Emma has had a rough few days…
Aug 5, 2025 7:49 pm
Yeah... nothing she did not bring upon herself, though, so we can't feel too bad for her. :)
Aug 5, 2025 8:23 pm
Well, I feel bad for the character; Persephone, on the hand, likely would not! lol. She's too busy trying not to feel anything at all.
Aug 5, 2025 8:35 pm
I'm embarrassed to say I have forgotten Persephone's last name. I can't find where I stated it, and I improved it when I did. If you don't mind, @vagueGM , I will use a placeholder name in my RP post and, if you don't recall either, I'll just go with that. Otherwise, I can correct in whichever way is easiest.
Aug 5, 2025 8:36 pm
Persephone Mei Zhang
Aug 5, 2025 8:40 pm
Ah yes, thank you!

You do not have permission to post in this thread.